The New Jersey men's soccer team lost 2-1 in overtime to Yeshiva University to end their 2013 season. The loss dropped the Knights to 6-10-2, their worst record in three seasons. They ended the season on a five match losing streak.

The Knights fell behind 1-0 early in the second half before tying the match in dramatic fashion at the 86:08 mark on a goal by Oluwatoby Jato on an assist by Ray Scalfani. The match then went into overtime and after what appeared to be a good scoring opportunity for the Knights, the Maccabees countered and scored the winning goal only 1:21 into overtime.